Why Prefer Zinc Glycinate Over Zinc Sulphate?

Zinc glycinate vs zinc sulphate, in short
Zinc glycinate is zinc chelated with the amino acid glycine. Zinc sulphate is an inorganic zinc salt. Both supply zinc in animal feed, but the chelated form is absorbed better and held in the body for longer, so less of it ends up in the manure. In the pig study described below, apparent zinc absorption in the stomach was 15.7% for the zinc amino acid chelate and negative (minus 18.3%) for zinc sulphate.
| Zinc glycinate | Zinc sulphate | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Zinc chelated with the amino acid glycine | An inorganic zinc salt |
| Absorption | Higher | Lower in every part of the gut in the study below |
| Retention | Held in the organs for longer after feeding stops | Shorter |
| Losses | Less zinc in dung and urine | The larger part ends up in the manure |
Why Zinc is necessary?
Zinc is an essential micronutrient required by all animals. A lack of it in the feed can have serious consequences, such as decreased feed intake, decreased growth, impaired immune function, and decreased fertility in the animals. In the past, trace elements were added to the feed in the form of inorganic salts such as sulphates and oxides. Only a limited percentage was absorbed by the animal – the major part ended up in the manure. It’s a colossal waste, both monetarily and ecologically.
There are considerable interactions in homeostasis as well as functions of essential elements, and in particular between zinc, calcium, copper, and iron. It is therefore necessary to consider the ratios of elements in feeds for the optimal amount of zinc in diets.
SK Minerals makes this. See zinc glycinate, feed grade.
Zinc, in the form of its divalent metal ion, Zn2+, is nutritionally essential for all living organisms. The total amount of zinc in the human body is 23 g, and its concentrations in tissues are about the same in all mammals.Virtually all its functions are in proteins, in which it is a catalytic, structural, or regulatory co-factor.
Organically-bound trace elements such as Glycinates are proposed in animal feeds since they show higher bioavailability than inorganic zinc salts.(Ref.3).
This results in increased animal performance and better animal vitality and productivity.
Glycine is a compound of glycinate, the smallest essential amino acid. It is used in the food industry as a source of zinc and amino acid for food and feed additives, as a fertilizer, as an amino acid agent for drug preparation, as a seasoning agent, as a saccharin, and as an agent for brewing, meat processing, and cold drink preparation.
Zinc Glycinate better than inorganic Zinc sulphate
Zinc absorption was lower in all segments of the gastrointestinal tract of pigs fed zinc sulphate versus pigs fed zinc amino acid chelates (p 0.01).The apparent absorption coefficients in the stomach were negative for zinc sulphate (–18.3%) and positive for zinc amino acid chelate (15.7%). This was the first published study that demonstrated that when zinc is chelated to amino acids, it, and presumably other metal amino acid chelates, can be absorbed directly into the blood from the mucosal tissue of the stomach.
Why does chelating a mineral with amino acids boost its absorption?
The solution comes from understanding that the intestinal absorption pathway for an amino acid chelate differs from the ones used for metal ion absorption.
While the increased absorption of amino acid chelates is widely recognised, the absorption mechanism is not well understood. This might be because most researchers first thought of the amino acid chelate as a metallic molecule rather than assuming it to be absorbed as a protein rich molecule.
The amino acid chelated metal gives better performance due to bioavailability and retention of zinc within various vital body organs like the heart, liver, stomach, lungs, etc. Moreover, the animal body retains the level of zinc for a longer time if we stop its administration than the inorganic metal salts. The absorbency of amino acid chelated zinc salt is quite high vis-a-vis comparison with inorganic zinc salt.


